When the IRS fails to explain how it calculated a penalty, is the penalty automatically invalid?
Prejudice is required before the Tax Court will seriously consider striking a penalty that is missing the underlying calculation. That is the lesson from Groves v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-86. In that case, the taxpayer, Mr. Groves, organized DAD (Distressed Asset Debt) transactions, which were listed transactions. In 2013, the IRS assessed penalties under IRC § 6707 (an assessable penalty), which requires a tax shelter organizer to register a tax shelter with the IRS. The IRS filed a tax lien for nonpayment of the penalty, which Mr. Groves challenged.
When the IRS asserts a penalty, IRC § 6751(a) requires the IRS to include a computation of how the penalty amount was determined. Section 6751(a) states that the IRS “shall include” with each notice of penalty the name of the penalty, the penalty Code section, and a computation of the penalty.
In the collection action, Mr. Groves asked the Tax Court to hold that, as a matter of law, the IRS Appeals officer abused her discretion by verifying that the IRS fully complied with section 6751(a). Mr. Groves argued that because the penalty notice did not include a computation, the penalty assessment was invalid.
The court agreed that the penalty notice omitted a calculation, but Mr. Groves was not prejudiced by the missing calculation. The court declined to hold that the penalty assessment was invalid and held that the IRS Appeals officer did not abuse her discretion.
In the memorandum opinion, the court noted, sometimes repeatedly, the following facts:
- Mr. Groves’s prior attorney received at least two penalty computations during the lifecycle of the case.
- The request for review of the collection activities did not specifically challenge the absence of a penalty computation under section 6751(a). The missing computation was not raised until four years later.
- The case activity record showed that the IRS Appeals officer reviewed the penalty computation and concluded the penalty computation was correct.
- Mr. Groves requested a penalty computation.
- Mr. Groves never alleged he was prejudiced.
The IRS’s failure to include a computation is not, standing alone, grounds to invalidate the penalty.
If you receive a penalty and do not understand how it was computed, ask the IRS. If you get no response (or an insufficient response), begin to build the case to show this omission was prejudicial. Raise the issue early (and often). It is not your job to do the IRS’s job, but because Congress did not include a remedy for the failure, the taxpayer’s case must be compelling for relief, whatever the form that might be.
If you receive a notice including a penalty, please contact the attorneys at K. Tyson Law. We have decades of experience interpreting and advising about the tax law associated with penalties.

